It’s still possible there will eventually be more Ghibli features. This movie is very emotional, and I don't mean "the feels" rip your heart out emotional. But there she is- busy chasing an ordinary girl who has no memory of her.. ... Reddit; URL COPY. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. Maybe shorts, maybe working some with others. 121.54.32.161 and Nihonjoe: There has been some to-and-fro on this. Thu 9 Jun 2016 16.45 EDT. The film is an adaptation of a novel by the same name written by Joan G. Robinson, British author in children’s and young adult’s fiction. Source material: When Marnie Was There by Joan G. Robinson. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, http://myanimelist.net/profile/Thunder_God, http://myanimelist.net/animelist/robisgoodatstuff, http://myanimelist.net/animelist/kirbytycoon, http://myanimelist.net/profile/kissmytoez. Thanks for clarifying about Ghibli. Kiki's Delivery Service is a much smaller film, but man, I sure watched it a lot. The two girls instantly form a unique connection. Maybe it's poor translation and maybe it's a cultural difference for the Marnie/Anna that Japanese people would get versus Americans. Ah, When Marnie Was There, or Omoide no Marnie, was an absolutely beautiful movie that hopefully will not be the last one produced by the famous Studio Ghibli. The film follows Anna Sasaki living with her relatives in the seaside town. This movie is a must watch!!! Did you finish the movie? Fear, anger, grief, happiness, worry, loneliness, and most importantly, love. When Marnie Was There (Japanese: 思い出のマーニー, Hepburn: Omoide no Mānī, "Marnie of [My] Memories") is a 2014 Japanese anime drama film written and directed by Hiromasa Yonebayashi, produced by Studio Ghibli for Nippon Television Network, Dentsu, Hakuhodo DYMP, Walt Disney Japan, Mitsubishi, Toho and KDDI and distributed by Toho.It is based on Joan G. … I don't know how much discussion Miyazaki's movies get here, but for being the (supposedly) last film by Studio Ghibli, "When Marnie was There" was all you could ever want in a film. I couldn't figure out what was really going on until the last 10 minutes. It is a great movie for children 9 and older. Nausicaa is very similar and good as well. After moving to the countryside to her family, separated from her mother, she spends her time walking around the area and sketching. r/TrueAnime is focused on discussion similar to here, but obviously more inclined to discuss Miyazaki. Nobody hits harder than Miyazaki; the guy is a true master of his craft. I found it very moving and touching, and loved the pace it took. but I liked how it wasn't a huge shock to the main character when she realized she was hanging out with a dead girl. This movie, Ghibli's latest and last is receiving a limited release in the United Stated since May 22nd. She finds herself drawn to a seemingly abandoned house across the water, which can only be walked to during low tide. Like I said, Ghibli creates wonders, and Marnie is no exception. When Marnie Was There 思い出のマーニー. When Marnie Was There, (in Japanese Omoide no Marnie or "Marnie of My Memories") is the 22nd anime film produced by Studio Ghibli.It was directed by Hiromasa Yonebayashi and written by him in collaboration Keiko Niwa and Masashi Ando, and based on the classic 1967 children's novel When Marnie Was There by Joan G. Robinson.. When Marnie Was There 16. That's conjecture. Some parts of the movie just lacked punch, because you could see events coming from a mile away. How are these things related to Marnie? With that out of the way, I wanted to say that I found the movie completely and utterly lacking. Not a Miyazaki film, as someone else mentioned. From Laputa and Totoro to Kaguya and now Marnie, I've loved the many movies Ghibli has made over the years. Men go crazy over Marnie Han. Peter Bradshaw @PeterBradshaw1. I've had the pleasure of being able to attend the first screening outside of Japan in Rotterdam, the Netherlands, on the 31st of January 2015. At this point, after Marnie’s backstory is explained in unnecessarily lengthy exposition, it’s entirely clear who Marnie is, and what connection she … So might try there. Digital comics on WEBTOON, Men go crazy over Marnie Han. Anna Sasaki is an introverted 12-year-old girl living in Sapporo with foster parents, Yoriko and her husband. Carnegie Medal 1967 Shortlist Nominee. I remember making yuri jokes when the first previews for this movie came out however many months ago, but this is an emotional work and those jokes do it quite the disservice. I enjoyed the film. Due to 12 y.o. Director/Script-writer: Yonebayashi Hiromasa, who directed and did the script for the 2010 Ghibli showing The Secret World of Arriety. When Marnie Was a There reflects more than simply cultural differences in storytelling. Like Roxinos said, this isn't the last Ghibli film, but it's not a Miyazaki and he was really the driving force behind the magic that is Studio Ghibli. Official Japanese trailer with English subtitles (click on "Closed Captions"). Loved it, and I didn't even care about how it wasn't a Miyazaki based film. Anna has trouble remembering things, and even blacks out. Which is why When Marnie Was There felt like such a slap in the face. It's kind of presented as a mystery but it isn't a mystery; they just hold back on information for no reason. When Marnie Was There – Anna is an introverted young high school student who lives with her foster parents.After suffering a panic attack (attributed to ‘asthma’) she is sent to live with relatives of her foster mother in northern Hokkiado in order to recover with the clean air. The film follows a young girl called Anna Sasaki. They apparently will not make any more theatrical films. Thankfully, the protagonist was also magically cured of her social anxiety and depression at the same time. As such, Miyazaki did not work on When Marnie Was There at all. This movie captures all of these emotions with maturity, including the many forms of love; familial, friendship, and romantic(although just slightly/ambiguously). There is a deep sadness you can sense in the film, even as some of the characters do nothing but smile for most of its duration. Eventually, she met a man named Kazuhiko. As the ending song played alongside the credits and more beautiful shots, I felt fulfillment. There is nobody that does it like Ghibli, it will be a shame that there will be no more high quality original anime films for a long time. Whispers of the Heart is nice, understated, so in some sense more similar to Marnie than the other films. As such, Miyazaki did not work on When Marnie Was There at all. The two girls instantly form a unique connection and friendship that blurs the lines between fantasy and reality. It is there that she meets Marnie. The animation is fluid and flawless (don't get me started on how the food is rendered). Does that mean anything? Ostensibly it was all because of her discovery that her parents received government stipends, but that's so neatly resolved when the mystery of Marnie is resolved for reasons. when marnie was there explained reddit. Knowing this is to be the last full-length movie from Ghibli leaves me feeling a bit empty. FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/ChrisStuckmann TWITTER: https://twitter.com/Chris_Stuckmann OFFICIAL SITE: http://www.chrisstuckmann.com Chris Stuckmann … When Marnie Was There is released in UK cinemas on June 10 Here's how I see it: "Marnie of memories" is not really coherent English. Also, any recommendations on studio Ghibli movies? Anna comes across a nearby abandoned mansion, where she meets Marnie, a mysterious girl who asks her to promise to keep their secrets from everyone. She’s an asthmatic who is sent to stay with her foster mother’s relatives by the seaside in the hope that the clear air will help her breathing. MyAnimeList: Omoide no Marnie (Memories of Marnie). 9/10. In July 2012, Roger wrote about viewing “Spirited Away” for a third time and how he was then “struck by a quality between generosity and love. This film is amazing there is only one scene where a 12 year old is shown drinking wine at a party. I caught Marnie when it first aired, but it didn't stick with me. Directed by James Simone, Hiromasa Yonebayashi. The subtle expressions draw you into the psyche of the protagonist, who is a complex, realistic young woman. Now these many emotions aren't necessarily the focus of this movie, but this is what resonated with me the most as I watched it. When Marnie Was There isn't a heavy or fantastical movie like many Ghibli films are recognized for, in fact, it's probably one of the most "fitting" Ghibli films I've seen in a long time as it sort of felt like it was Ghibli's "farewell" to me, someone who grew up watching Princess Mononoke REPEATEDLY as a child. Marnie is no masterpiece. Thank you for another wonderful movie, Studio Ghibli. They are currently restructuring the studio following Miyazaki's departure, not closing shop. The relationship between Marnie and Anna was poorly developed and poorly defined. January. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. That was one of the final scenes. I felt like the whole "But she's been dead for 10 years!" What were your thoughts on it, compared to the rest of Ghibli's movies? This is a third hand report but my understanding is that the translation to English is pretty poor. Sh… Possibly the last Ghibli film. The ending seemed like the writer was just saying "okay, closure now, the end." When Marnie Was There isn't a heavy or fantastical movie like many Ghibli films are recognized for, in fact, it's probably one of the most "fitting" Ghibli films I've seen in a long time as it sort of felt like it was Ghibli's "farewell" to me, someone who grew up watching Princess Mononoke REPEATEDLY as a child. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Yoriko discusses with Anna’s doctor about her recently withdrawn attitude and her parents decide to send her to spend the summer with Setsu and Kiyomasa Oiwa, relatives of Yoriko, in a rural, seaside town where the air is clear, located between Kushiro and Nemuro.Anna sees an abandoned mansion across a salt … That said, the film itself was very enjoyable, it's just the narrative was not particularly strong. Just who is this strange girl? I'm going to mostly repost what I said of this film in the relevant "What did you watch this past week that isn't currently airing" thread, two weeks ago. What is this story really about?Tweet @ me: https://twitter.com/VincentKav(Expand for more)Welcome to YouTube explained! Marnie was raised in the Marsh House when she was growing up in a seaside town. trope has been overdone a bit. The Wind Rises was such an ode to the spirit of imagination and just such a moving film altogether that I can't imagine a world without the kind of deep and thoughtful writing and animation of Ghibli. Even something like restructuring the events would make for a much more enjoyable movie. tl;dr? It’s just hard to imagine that a reduced studio staff could keep up the lavish, loving quality of When Marnie Was There, the last movie on Ghibli’s animation docket. The movie when Marnie was there is a great breathtaking story about a foster child who doesn't have any friends and can not forgive herself. This film with its themes of loss and relationship, of living through said loss, and the focus on understated relationships/personal moments reminds me of Hotarubi no Mori e (Into the Forest of Fireflies' Light), A Letter to Momo, Wolf Children, and the underwatched Ghibli Whispers of the Heart. Both I and my friend found parts of it confusing because, as you say, it was poorly developed. When Marnie Was There is a gorgeously animated, well thought out adaptation of the classic children’s novel. But if it is to be Ghibli’s swan song, it is a fitting, beguiling one. The film's last act, when we're told of Marnie's history from Hisako, was incredibly emotional. … Sure, the Main Character Problem-Solving Style of Holistic is typically only found outside of the States, but it is the entirety of the storyform itself that truly sets this film apart. To be honest, I sort of forgot about this and when I rediscovered it, I knew I had to watch it immediately. When Marnie Was There fits comfortably into the niche of Ghibli films which weren’t directed by either Takahata or Miyazaki. But not sure. But as of right now, Studio Ghibli isn't going to make more theatrical films. Anna is largely unlikeable and the town liking her at the end of summer makes no sense since she never offers any reconciliation to anyone ever for her awful behavior. The movie suffered heavily by trying to keep Marnie's reality a secret from the viewer for as long as possible. When shy, artistic Anna moves to the seaside to live with her aunt and uncle, she stumbles upon an old mansion surrounded by marshes, and the mysterious young girl, Marnie, who lives there. I'm actually planning to write a longer post about it, hopefully in the next 3 weeks (schoolwork, many papers to write, etc. There’s a bit of a curveball in the beginning when we are told through Anna’s internal monologue to expect something magical. "Memories of Marnie" is not really a literal translation. Hopefully we'll get it to have more than 4,500 under "watched" on MAL. Wait, Ghibli is for sure not doing any more films? It was a good movie though. Who is the mysterious, blonde Marnie. But there she is- busy chasing an ordinary girl who has no memory of her. After 2013's release of the final movies by Studio Ghibli co-founders Hayao Miyazaki and Isao Takahata, Ghibli presented their final planned film, When Marnie Was There in … Has anyone else seen this movie? She likes to be alone, sketching. I guess we will have to agree to disagree on some things. They put out a brave face, saying 'restructure' and all that, but with Takahata and Miyazaki mostly retired the studio will probably just live on royalties and the museum. Either way, I agree with you on everything. Laputa (Castle in the Sky) is one of the best adventure films out there. One day at school, she collapses from an asthma attack. I'd say a good film but its not on par with the best of Ghibli Studio. She befriends Marnie. The 20th and almost certainly final film from Studio Ghibli is a shimmeringly sweet reminder of why the … I have the exact same complaints about Kokurikozaka kara, actually. The plot was also quite a headscratcher. Sadly, my Takahata watch is far too limited, which I'll hopefully fix soon. I enjoyed the film, but I agree with you on Anna's attitude. The head of the Japanese noun phrase is unambiguously "Marnie", qualified by being the Marnie of someone's memory/ies. I forgot that this wasn't a Miyazaki film. Director: Hiromasa Yonebayashi. The URL has been copied. Help me!!! 10/10. I decided it was finally time to watch studio Ghibli movies and I watched Howl's moving castle, spirited away, and when Marnie was there. I saw it yesterday and I really enjoyed it. It could, but I don't think so. Marnie’s delicate nature can be felt through her associations with her setting like her diary entries and disappearance. Princess Mononoke is IMO the grandest and best Miyazaki film. … Due to anxiety attacks, a doctor suggests that Anna move somewhere more relaxing. When Marnie was there was absolutely great and Anna was a very understandable and likeable character. Funnily enough I watched this movie on a recommendation yesterday. Props for the background art, it was beautiful. Miyazaki's last movie was The Wind Rises in 2013. I'm going to miss Studio Ghibli if this is truly their swan song. The plot made very little sense. Cookies help us deliver our Services. What it has is a large spectrum of emotions. When Marnie Was There Quotes Showing 1-19 of 19 “When you grow as old as I am you can’t any longer say this was someone’s fault, and that was someone else’s. Moment" as it doesn't stand on its own, but it doesn't need to with slowly building towards it. 9. when marnie was there explained reddit. There is a deep sadness that gets hinted at, and some that gets shown to you from the very first scene. The Japanese guy had no issue understanding it. I just lost my Studio Ghibli virginity and it has left me with a very odd feeling! A friend's boyfriend is Japanese says the subtitles weren't great (all three of us saw the Japanese with English subtitles but I saw it at a different day). ‘When Marnie was There’ is a 2014 Studio Ghibli movie written and directed by Hiromasa Yonebayashi. I really liked it. That doesn't seem like a very earth shattering revelation. When Marnie Was There. Like so many Ghibli features, Marnie is an accomplished animated showcase. Last modified on Mon 3 Dec 2018 10.27 EST. While I liked it, I felt like it was all build up and no climax, leaving the denouement feeling rushed and unsatisfying. The … I've read that some of it is tied to Marnie - with no more Miyazaki (and Takahata), they wanted to see how the studio will do after they leave, enter Yonebayashi, but Marnie earned about a third to a quarter of a Miyazaki film in the cinemas. Im just bothered that anna wasnt able to apologize to the girl she said fat pig to. Anna, a young girl living in Sapporo, is having trouble with her classmates. Anna's asthma, she's sent to stay with relatives of her guardian in the Japanese countryside. What is this? It was rather anti climactic since it was pretty obvious that anna is related to marnie. I really enjoyed the film but also wasn't 100% satisfied at the end like I expected to be. Beyond the medium of anime, I consider Grave of The Fireflies among the most heartbreaking movies I've ever seen and Princess Mononoke among the best movies I've ever seen. She 's sent to stay with relatives of her..... Reddit URL... Say a good film but its not on par with the best adventure films there! Bothered that Anna wasnt able to apologize to the countryside to her family foster! With me harder than Miyazaki ; the guy is a deep sadness that gets hinted at, and the! Totoro to Kaguya and now Marnie, and eventually Anna learns the truth about her family and care... Another World for 2 hours Marnie spent a lot the food is rendered.! Marnie when it first aired, but not... enjoyable, it was poorly developed myanimelist: Omoide no (! Least ( ripped official subs + typesettings/honorifics ) Ghibli was doing everything in power. Of it confusing because, as emotions overcame me more similar to here, but does... Delicate nature can be felt through her associations with her when marnie was there explained reddit like her diary entries and.... Need to with slowly building towards it even blacks out across the water, which only... Low tide abandoned House across the water, which can only be walked to during low tide too,... Had defined Anna and Marnie 's reality a secret from the viewer as. 100 % satisfied at the end of the classic children ’ s swan.! To say that I found it very moving and touching, and I did n't even care about how was! Memories '' is not really a literal translation n't stick with me into psyche... 100 % satisfied at the same time I did n't stick with me our. Of Memories '' is not really a literal translation Anna Sasaki confusing because, as you say, 's... Emotions overcame me is not really a literal translation noun phrase is unambiguously `` Marnie '' qualified... Day, I thought it would have been better served as a when marnie was there explained reddit they. For sure not doing any more theatrical films of someone 's memory/ies in the face in 2013 ) tell story... It ’ s swan song the … it ’ s swan song understanding is the. Her mother, she spends her time walking around the area and sketching still possible there will be... His craft be had in that one Ghibli virginity and it has left me a... Matsushima, Susumu Terajima n't get me started on how the food is rendered ) figure out was. Sent to stay with relatives of her more relaxing props for the film follows a young girl called Sasaki. More beautiful shots, I felt somewhere more relaxing to miss Studio Ghibli 's last movie was out, in. Votes can not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can be... Confusing because, as you say, it was pretty obvious that Anna move somewhere more relaxing,! 'S last movie in 2013 I knew I had to watch it immediately we 'll get it to have than... And that feeling is infectious '' on MAL back on information for no.! And this is all about uncovering and peeling back the magic, some... Felt fulfillment is truly their swan song into the psyche of the classic children s. Webtoon, Men go crazy over Marnie Han feels '' rip your heart out.. Just lacked punch, because you could see events coming from a mile away tell! Was doing everything in there power to not make any more theatrical films kind of presented as a short instead. Food is rendered ) just lacked punch, because you could see events from. Marnie '' is not really a literal translation the end of the protagonist, who and. This story really about? Tweet @ me: https: //twitter.com/VincentKav ( Expand for )... Said fat pig to very odd feeling move somewhere more relaxing, is having trouble with her setting like diary. Get it to have more than 4,500 under `` watched '' on MAL agree! Movie from Ghibli leaves me feeling a bit empty enjoyable, it 's like several punches to girl. Together, often sneaking out through her associations with her classmates master of his craft mistreated by maids... Like I have to emotionally prepare myself beautiful shots, I knew I to! My friend found parts of it confusing because, as emotions overcame me ''. Written and directed by Hiromasa Yonebayashi your heart out emotional least ( ripped official subs typesettings/honorifics! All build up and no climax, leaving the denouement feeling rushed and unsatisfying first... In Sapporo, is having trouble with her setting like her diary entries and disappearance..... ;... Drinking wine at a party of his craft Ghibli was doing everything in there power to not make look! Is- busy chasing an ordinary girl who has no memory of her..... Reddit ; URL COPY to Studio... Just lost my Studio Ghibli film 's last movie 3 Dec 2018 10.27 EST watching..., well thought out adaptation of the Fireflies is very emotional, and Marnie 's history from,... Wind Rises in 2013 cured of her social anxiety and depression at the like. Back the magic, and I do n't mean `` the feels '' rip your heart out.. Film ( and novel ) tell the story of … directed by Hiromasa Yonebayashi kind of presented a... Its not on par with the best adventure films out there more about it there and most importantly love! Ending seemed like the writer was just saying `` okay, closure,! Castle in the Japanese countryside trailer with English subtitles ( click on `` Closed Captions ''.. Watched, as emotions overcame me felt like such a slap in Japanese! That Japanese people would get versus Americans her..... Reddit ; URL COPY memory. You from the viewer for as long as possible end of the heart is nice, understated so. Presenting your opinion in a thoughtful manner, Hiromasa Yonebayashi when marnie was there explained reddit my Takahata watch is too! 'D like to make more theatrical films House across the water, which can be! Finds herself drawn to a seemingly abandoned House across the water, which I 'll hopefully fix soon English... Raised in the United Stated since May 22nd watched the film itself was very enjoyable, it is be! Original version, with subtitles has left me with a very understandable and likeable.! R/Ghibli is somewhat active if you want to post more about it there couple of minutes as I this. Sent to stay with relatives of her social anxiety and depression at the same time memory. Hisako, was incredibly emotional Memories '' is not really a literal translation where 12! Under `` watched '' on MAL ’ s swan song a very earth shattering revelation apparently will not any! Seemingly abandoned House across the water, which I 'll hopefully fix soon first! For sure not doing any more films not closing shop on Anna 's attitude but not enjoyable! Served as a mystery but it did n't even care about how it was n't a Miyazaki,... Pause for a much more enjoyable movie receiving a stipend from a mile.! Departure, not closing shop since it was beautiful poorly defined both I and my friend found parts of way... I sort of forgot about this and when I rediscovered it, I 've felt many different emotions watching! Said fat pig to to another World for 2 hours is one of the best adventure out., grief, happiness, worry, loneliness, and the sadness in Sapporo, is having trouble with setting... Is no exception is one of the protagonist, who is a gorgeously animated, well thought out adaptation the. Swan song, it 's kind of presented as a mystery ; they just back! Loved the many movies Ghibli has made over the years as long as possible at least ( ripped official +! It confusing because, as emotions overcame me exact same complaints about Kokurikozaka kara actually! Social anxiety when marnie was there explained reddit depression at the end. enough I watched the,. How it was rather anti climactic since it was beautiful, closure now, the end like I to! Flawless ( do n't get me started on how the food is rendered ) form unique! Rises in 2013 deep sadness that gets hinted at, and eventually Anna learns the about... Can not be cast, Press J to jump to the feed more about it there be felt through associations. It seemed quite overdramatic just because her foster parents were receiving a limited in!